1. Skip to navigation
  2. Skip to content
  3. Skip to sidebar
The National College Magazine
Current Issue
Select Previous Issues
Summer 2010
U Magazine
Spring 2010
U Magazine
Winter 2009
U Magazine
Fall 2009
U Magazine
Spring 2009
U Magazine
20th Anniversary Issue
U Magazine
Summer 2008
U Magazine
Spring 2008
U Magazine
Winter 2007
U Magazine
Fall 2007
U Magazine
Summer 2007
U Magazine
Spring 2007
U Magazine
Winter 2006
U Magazine
Fall 2006
U Magazine
Summer 2006
U Magazine
Spring 2006
U Magazine
Winter 2005
U Magazine
Fall 2005
U Magazine
Summer 2005
U Magazine
Spring 2005
U Magazine
Winter 2004
U Magazine
Fall 2004
U Magazine
Spring 2004
U Magazine
Winter 2003
Fall 2003
Spring 2003

U.Mag's Top 25 Articles
From wacky college stories to celebrity interviews, these are our favorite U. articles of all time.
Binge Drinking: A College National Pastime?
Body Image: Taken Too Seriously?
Crime on Campuses
Campus Clips
Admissions Without SAT
Is Your School Cool?
Master's Degree: Worth It?
Tech Talk
Student CEO's
Digital Plagiarism
Turn Off Your Cell Phone!
Online Exclusives
Backpack Europe
Find advice before you go.
1-800 Database
Full of dial-up help.
Arts & Entertainment
NC-17: It Ain't Right!
Dr. Drew On the Web
Dixie Chicks Set To Fly
Cooking w/ Chef Rossi
One Pot Suppers
Pasta Bada-Bing!
Cocktail Hour Munchies
Health & Nutrition
Brain Food for Finals
Abstinence on Campus
Suicide Gene?
U. Archives
Find a College or University
Get Help Writing Your Admissions Essay
Financial Aid
Find a Scholarship

Print this article

To give or not to give? That's the question some college donors may be asking themselves in the wake of recent lawsuits. A handful of schools, including Yeshiva U., Allan Hancock College, the U. of Alabama and the U. of California, Irvine, are taking donors who renege on their donation promises to court to collect the dough.

Mrs. Richard Barclay may wish her husband had thought twice about his gift to UC Irvine: $1 million toward the construction of a 756-seat theater. Following her husband's death, Mrs. Barclay refused to fulfill the $600,000 remainder of her husband's pledge. The City of Irvine, along with the nonprofit operating company that runs the theater, sued the widow, and Mrs. Barclay eventually paid a portion of the promised amount.

Also caught in a legal battle over donations were the family of Hugh Culverhouse. His widow, Joy McCann Culverhouse, sued the U. of Alabama in May 1997 to nullify the pledge her husband had made to Alabama's business school. The school filed a counter-suit for a share of the family's foundation, and the Culverhouse family was forced to cough up a whopping $16 million to the university.

Sound heartless? Not to Cornell U. senior Carl Winter, who says donors should be bound to their agreements. "If a written promise of donation is agreed upon, the donor should be held responsible. It's like a contract," he says.

But some students think punishing donors for pinching pennies is a bit harsh. Nicholas Frutiger, a senior at the U. of Georgia, says, "It seems wholly unfair to legally penalize someone for a sudden lack of generosity."

So after graduation rolls around and your friendly, neighborhood alumni society starts harassing you for donations, don't just agree with 'em to get off the phone – you might find yourself in court.

By Anna Attkisson, U. of Kansas/Illustration By Joel Coughlin, Buffalo State U.

Print this article